Tuesday, November 17, 2026

M31 Battle Report 8-3: Sudden Strike

    "We have bled across a hundred ash-choked plains to reach this moment, brothers. Now ride like the storm's edge and cut through the traitors and then disappear like the morning mist."

-Khan Muqal, Brotherhood of the Broken Blade 

Background

This is the third battle in the final phase of the campaign for the Xhorik System during the Horus Heresy. (See the M31 Campaign Summary Page for links to all the battles.) Knowing the system is already lost, the White Scars are making an attempt to disrupt and decapitate the Traitor forces, ostensibly to weaken them and delay their march to Terra, but mostly to claw back a scrap of their honor by killing the enemies that defeated them.

They had become Sagyar Mazan and renamed themselves the Brotherhood of the Broken Blade. Now they would seek to claim blood for blood, but with a special focus on killing the most hated leaders of the Traitors.  

After their unexpected victory in the heart of New Barbarus, the White Scars stayed true to their nature and made a sudden strike deeper into enemy territory. Units of World Eaters were closing in from all sides and both sides found themselves in a deadly city fight, racing to grab objectives and then moving on quickly before they could be overwhelmed. 



Scenario: Sudden Strike

The third core scenario from the Siege of Cthonia book:

Prior to deployment, players alternate placing six objective markers. At the end of each player's turn, he may select a number of objective markers he controls, up to the allowed limit. For each objective selected, he scores 1 VP and the objective marker is then removed from the game.

Turn 1: 0 objectives may be claimed
Turn 2: 1 objective may be claimed
Turns 3 and 4: 2 objectives may be claimed

Secondary Objectives:
Slay the Warlord: 1 VP + 1 VP if the warlord is a Primarch
Giant Killer (Destroy super-heavy, knight, or titan): 2 VP
Last Man Standing (have more units at the end of the game): 1 VP
Break Their Ranks (destroy a unit first turn): 1 VP  + 1 VP if it was an Elites or HQ choice

Game Length: 4 Turns


An industrial district of New Barbarus. Both sides must quickly achieve their objectives and keep moving in a deadly game of cat and mouse.



Belligerents:

World Eaters - The Crimson Path (Pete)

Praeotr Ghrodd the Slaughter Lord 
Rampagers
Apothecary Detachment
Tactical Squad [Line]
Tactical Squad [Line]
Chaplain (with Despoilers)
Despoiler Squad in Rhino [Line]
Recon Squad [Line]
Red Butchers
Land Raider Proteus
Contemptor Dreadnought with chainfist with meltagun and Gravis Lascannon
Predator Squadron



White Scars - Chogorian Brotherhood (Phil)

Praetor Khan Muqal
Stormseer Qiu Tongmi, Spirit Immortal
Recon Squad in Rhino [Line]
Tactical Squad in Rhino [Line]
Tactical Squad in Rhino [Line]
Legion Outrider Squadron [Line]
Skyhunter Squadron [Line] 
Contemptor Dreadnought with Gravis powerfist with heavy flamer and Gravis Lascannon
Sabre Strike Tank Squadron with neutron blasters and heavy bolters
Tactical Support Squad (reserves)
Dreadclaw Drop Pod (reserves)
Legion Destroyer Assault Squad (reserves)
Xiphon Interceptor (reserves)



The White Scars choose the deployment zone with better access to the objectives. This time it is the World Eaters who deploy their infiltrators on top of an objective.


World Eaters Recon Squad The Butchers' Eyes infiltrates forward to secure objective 3, the wrecked superheavy tank.

Outriders and Sabres deploy on the White Scars' left flank, near objective 1, the supply depot.

The World Eaters deploy their Predators across the Outriders and Sabre Strike Tanks. A tactical squad uses the battle tanks as cover for their advance.

On the World Eaters' left, Ghrodd leads his Rampagers toward objective 6 on the sattelite dish.

Deployment view from the Loyalist right / Traitor left. 

The fast-moving White Scars get the first turn and concentrate their fire on the vulnerable Recon Squad.

Khan Muqal directs his Skyhunters to sweep toward the center, away from Ghrodd's Rampagers, so they can lend their fire to eliminate the nearby Recon squad.

The Outriders sweep around behind the Sabres, using the tanks as a screen. The Traitor Predators use their reaction to advance straight toward the smaller tanks.

The Sabre Strike Tanks may be small and light, but their neutron blasters pack an outsized punch and one Predator is wrecked.

The White Scars Recon Squad disembarks from their Rhino and climbs onto chemical plant, objective 2.

The White Scars first tactical squad also disembarks to bring their bolters to bear on The Butchers' Eyes. The squad is destroyed, giving the Loyalists a VP for Break Their Ranks.

White Scars Turn 1: The bikes and jetbikes swing inward from the flanks. The center advances and destroys the Recon Squad and one Predator. The Contemptor damages the Land Raider.

White Scars: 1
World Eaters: 0

The World Eaters Chaplain and Despoiler Squad advance in their blood-splattered Rhino. They use the multimelta to destroy a White Scars Rhino, even after it used Fall Back to get out of close range. The Traitors also score Break Their Ranks (we later decided a dedicated transport alone should not score this since it is not a unique Force Organization slot).

The remaining Predator strikes back with the magna-melta and destroys a Sabre in return.

The second World Eaters tactical squad advances behind their wall of steel.

World Eaters Turn 1: Everything advances. The Predator and Rhino destroy a Loyalist Sabre and Rhino. The Landraider wounds a Skyhunter (he should have died since his T5 does not change Instant Death threshold).


White Scars: 1
World Eaters: 1

The Khan continues to evade and shoot from a safe distance, although they inflict very little damage on the tough Rampagers with their apothecary. The Xiphon Interceptor arrives. I think it destroys the World Eaters Rhino here...

The Contemptors exchange Gravis Lascannon fire, the Traitor using a reaction to Return Fire.


The World Eaters Despoilers disembark from their Rhino, presumably because it is wrecked by the Xiphon but I cannot remember for sure.

The remaining Sabre, the Rhino, and the Outriders combine to destroy the second Predator. The Outriders control objective 1.

White Scars Turn 2: The Outriders score objective 1 and remove it. The Contemptors wound each other. The World Eaters Rhino and remaining Predator are wrecked.

White Scars: 2
World Eaters: 1


The World Eaters tactical squad advances on the objective, ready to charge the Outriders. But the White Scars use Chasing the Wind to immediately move all the nearby units out of charge range, leaving the World Eaters furiously looking around for someone to fight!

The Land Raider Proteus advances, discharging the blood-encrusted Red Butchers! The Contemptor and tactical squad advance to objective 4.

The White Scars Contemptor uses Fall Back to force the Butchers to make a longer charge, but he is laid low by the Land Raider's lascannons before the assault phase anyway!

The Despoilers who disembarked from their wrecked Rhino advance and charge the White Scars tactical squad near objective 3. Their Chaplain, apothecary, and power weapons and assault bonus allow them to easily overwhelm the Loyalists.

With the Contemptor out of action, the Butchers instead assault the Rhino.

The White Scars find themselves pinned between two World Eaters assaults coming from both sides!

Both World Eaters assaults are victorious. The Rhino explodes, leaving the surviving eight tactical marines surrounded.

The White Scars are penned in by the jaws of a Traitor pincer.

World Eaters Turn 2: The Rampagers score objective 6 and remove it. The White Scars left flank leaves the World Eaters Chasing the Wind. The World Eaters launch a two pronged assault, crushing the White Scars center!

White Scars: 2
World Eaters: 2

The rest of the White Scars reserves finally arrive via deepstrike: the Dreadclaw carrying the Stormseer and tactical support squad, and the Destroyer Assault Squad weilding hand flamers and rad grenades.

The White Scars reserves arrive behind the World Eaters tactical squad on objective 4 and pour their concentrated fire into the surprised Traitors.

The World Eaters Despoiler squad charged so far forward into the White Scars center that it found itself isolated. The White Scars surrounded the Despoilers and whittled them down to only the Chaplain and one marine. (One Outrider must have melted down due to his plasma.)

Despite close range concentrated fire from two units and a psyker, only half the tactical squad is killed. 

The Destroyer Assault Squad charges and finishes off the Traitors with power lances, losing two of their own in return.

The White Scars launch their own pincer assault on the last of the Despoiler Squad, but the stubborn Traitors would not die!

After dispatching the tactical marines, the Destroyer Assault Squad consolidates back away from the dreadnought.

The Khan and his Skyhunters once again drop back out of charge range of the Butchers while continuing to spray them with fire, killing one and wounding another.

White Scars Turn 3: The Recon Squad scores objective 2 and removes it. The Xiphon must move straight forward, leaving it no targets, so it exits the battlefield to return for another run. The deepstrike reserves arrive and destroy a tactical squad. The White Scars center tries to crush the Despoilers in a pincer assault but fail miserably, leaving them unable to score a second objective for the turn!

White Scars: 3
World Eaters: 2


The very angry Contemptor lumbers toward the White Scars, guns firing.

Without a power fist, the Destroyer Assault Squad is helpless against the raging man-machine. Only the sergeant remains, fighting on alone. 

Now it is the Traitors' turn to once again close in on the Loyalists in the center!

The Red Butchers slaughter the tactical marines, but not before the White Scars kill the Chaplain. The Outriders speedy bikes are no help here and they are killed in a Sweeping Advance!


World Eaters Turn 3: The Rampagers score objective 5 and remove it. The flanks close in toward the center. Assaults destroy the White Scars tactical squad, Outriders, and Destroyer Assault Squad.

White Scars: 3
World Eaters: 3

For the second turn in a row, a World Eaters unit that emerged victorious from melee, is surrounded and gunned down by everything the White Scars can bring, including the Xiphon. The nigh-unstoppable Butchers are finally eliminated, leaving Khan Muqal and his Skyhunters in control of objective 3.

I have no idea how but apparently this sergeant and the Contemptor kill each other in melee!?

White Scars Turn 4: The Skyhunters score objective 3 and remove it. Everything in the center converges on the Butchers to eliminate them and the last Despoiler. The tactical support squad fires into the oncoming Rampagers, futilely trying to stop them from reaching objective 4.



The Rampagers move to objective 4, forgoing the chance to slaughter the White Scars tactical support squad in order to focus on the objectives. Ghrodd clearly has more willpower than most World Eaters!

The tactical squad from the World Eaters' right flank finally makes its way to the action, charging and destroying the White Scars Recon Squad.

The Rampagers scored all three of the Traitor objectives, but never got into melee!

World Eaters Turn 4: The Rampagers continue their sweep through the objectives, scoring objective 4. The tactical squad clears the White Scars Recon Squad. The Land Raider vaporizes a few tactical support marines out of spite.


I honestly cannot remember how this game turned out!

Piecing it together from the photos, I believe the Loyalists scored objectives 1, 2, and 3 while the Traitors captured 4, 5, and 6. Neither side scored Slay the Warlord or Giant Killer. The White Scars destroyed the Recon Squad in turn 1 for Break Their Ranks. In their first turn, the Traitors destroyed a Sabre and a Rhino. We were counting the Rhino as a unit, but in hindsight I would say you need to destroy the unit and its dedicated transport to count. So, it should have come down to Last Man Standing. Pete had a Praetor, Rampagers, tactical squad, and a Land Raider (4). I had a Praetor, a Stormseer, Skyhunters, Sabre, Rhino, tactical support squad, Xiphon, and Dreadclaw (8). 

The only question is if the Traitors should have scored objective 3 at the end of their turn 3: they were allowed to score two that turn and it appears they still had one Despoiler left with no White Scars around, but yet the objective marker is still visible in the photos of the White Scars turn 4 and the Skyhunters moved up close enough to score it. If the World Eaters scored this, it would take one VP from the Loyalists and give it to the Traitors, tipping the scale.

So did the White Scars win this one, making it an unheard of two in a row?! Or did we miss something?


Final Victory Points:
White Scars: 5
World Eaters: 4


Post-Game

When I first pulled these photos up, I felt like I had lost this game but when I go back and do my best to add up the VPs, it looks like the White Scars won, although it is very possible I mixed something up. You can only tell so much from a series of photos! In any case, this was a fun, fast-paced game between well-matched forces and it was a blast reliving it turn by turn through the photos and watching it unfold. This was possibly one of my favorite battle reports to write. 

I remember that during this final five-game phase of our campaign, I wanted to use every White Scars unit I had painted, so I mixed up my forces and Rites of War between games. Where I had used the Recon Company in the first two games, this time I went with the fast Line units of a Chogorian Brotherhood so I could zoom around the table, snagging objectives and then falling back before the really angry marines got there. Looking back at this list, it was probably the most mobile force I have ever taken, with a RoW that grants a bonus movement reaction. Other than the dreadnought, my lone heavy hitter, everything was fast moving. Part of the reason was because Chogorian Brotherhood doesn't let you take any heavy support except fliers, so I could not take my Sicarans. And of course I wanted to have as many fast-moving Line units as possible. Other than the Contemptor, my only melee punch was the Destroyer Assault Squad, and they do not hold up to any true assault specialists. In this battle, I would truly need to hit and run! It was a true test of speed vs strength.

Rewatching this battle, I feel I had a great strategy. I chose to deploy first and go first. That allowed Pete to setup hard counters to my forces, such as the Predators across from the Outriders, clearly hoping for a repeat of the last game's outcome! But by placing my most mobile units on the flanks, I could react by pulling them away from threats they could not match on their own. The left flank was executed to perfection: I swooped in, hit his tanks first, scored the objective, and then -finally- got a game-changing use of my Legion reaction to have my entire flank disappear when Pete tried to charge them. Pure White Scars poetry!

My biggest mistake was in the center, when I let myself get charged from both sides. I should have held back from those tempting objectives a bit longer since I could only score one on my second turn anyway and I had to prioritize objective 1. 

I played the Skyhunters more effectively here, always dancing away out of charge range while continuing to whittle down enemies from afar. I have learned my lesson that they are not for assaulting unless I have an insanely overwhelming advantage!

The Xiphon was disappointing, as my fliers tend to be in this edition, never dishing out much damage, although it may have destroyed a Rhino and helped finish off the Butchers. The deep strike assault force came in at the perfect place and time to ensure the World Eaters tactical squad could not score objective 4, but they were very underwhelming in firepower, barely killing a tactical squad and then being demolished by a dreadnought. The Destroyer Assault Squad is really only for taking out weak units, which is a battlefield role that is probably not worth their high points cost. Although that sergeant deserves high honors for somehow taking down the Contemptor in melee using a power glaive!

I also avoided the Rampagers all game as they were forced to grab objectives for victory points. This allowed more of my army to survive to the end, but meant I had to keep falling back and giving Pete open objectives. I just do not have anything that can reliably deal with that unit so giving up a VP per turn to keep them out of the battle seemed a fair trade. (If I tried to contest an objective, I would have lost the unit and the objective anyway.)

I had a lot of fun bobbing and weaving, hitting and running, and generally playing like the White Scars in the stories. I have learned that many of the units are underwhelming on their own and I need to concentrate the fire of a LOT of units at once in order to eliminate anything. I think this flimsy, mobile force performed about as well as it could in this battle that rewarded grabbing objectives and did not require holding them. 

I'll ask Pete who he remembers winning, but either way, this was a great game.








No comments:

Post a Comment